Movies Like Supernatural

Loved Supernatural? These 24 movies and shows share its DNA — surfaced by our semantic engine from theme, mood, cast and genre, then ranked by how closely they match. Every pick includes cast, ratings, trailers and streaming options.

24 titles

Haunted 1995 ★ 6.1

Fantasy Island 2020 ★ 5.8

Blackwater Lane 2024 ★ 6.0

Beetlejuice 1988 ★ 7.4

Leviticus 2026 ★ 6.8

[REC] 2007 ★ 7.2

The Medium 2021 ★ 7.0

The Prodigy 2019 ★ 6.2

Demon City 2025 ★ 6.9

Insidious 2011 ★ 6.9

The Cleansing Hour 2019 ★ 6.3

The Hole 2001 ★ 6.2

Followed 2020 ★ 5.9

The Howling 1981 ★ 6.6

The Long Hair of Death 1964 ★ 6.3

It Lives Inside 2023 ★ 5.7

I Am Not a Serial Killer 2016 ★ 6.3

The Boogeyman 2023 ★ 6.4

Toolbox Murders 2004 ★ 5.6

Pure 2019 ★ 5.5

Superstition 1982 ★ 6.1

Paranormal Activity 2007 ★ 6.1

Grave Encounters 2011 ★ 6.3

House of 1000 Corpses 2003 ★ 6.2