Movies Like Creepy AF

Loved Creepy AF? These 24 movies and shows share its DNA — surfaced by our semantic engine from theme, mood, cast and genre, then ranked by how closely they match. Every pick includes cast, ratings, trailers and streaming options.

24 titles

Spree 2020 ★ 6.4

Looks That Kill 2020 ★ 6.9

S.F.W. 1995 ★ 6.0

Freaky 2020 ★ 6.5

Deadstream 2022 ★ 6.3

Scary Movie 2000 ★ 6.4

#realityhigh 2017 ★ 6.2

The Night Before 1988 ★ 6.2

All About Evil 2010 ★ 5.9

Superstar 2012 ★ 5.1

Scream 1996 ★ 7.4

Confession of Murder 2012 ★ 7.1

Midnight 2021 ★ 7.2

Prodigal Son 2019 ★ 8.1

Natural Born Killers 1994 ★ 7.0

Caught in the Net 2020 ★ 7.9

Scream 2022 ★ 6.7

Character 2021 ★ 7.4

Bring Her Back 2025 ★ 7.3

The Guest 2014 ★ 6.6

Influencers 2025 ★ 6.2

The Return 2020 ★ 6.7

Following 2024 ★ 7.0

Happy Face 2025 ★ 6.8