Movies Like An Amish Sin

Loved An Amish Sin? These 24 movies and shows share its DNA — surfaced by our semantic engine from theme, mood, cast and genre, then ranked by how closely they match. Every pick includes cast, ratings, trailers and streaming options.

24 titles

Amish Grace 2010 ★ 7.0

An American Crime 2007 ★ 7.3

Hillbilly Elegy 2020 ★ 6.7

Love Finds You in Charm 2015 ★ 6.2

Maid 2021 ★ 8.0

The Unbreakable Boy 2025 ★ 7.7

The Glory 2022 ★ 8.5

Redeeming Love 2022 ★ 7.9

Till 2022 ★ 7.3

Good American Family 2025 ★ 7.6

Gimme Shelter 2013 ★ 6.6

The Magdalene Sisters 2002 ★ 7.4

Boy Erased 2018 ★ 7.0

Shahid 2013 ★ 7.3

Same Kind of Different as Me 2017 ★ 6.8

Witness 1985 ★ 7.1

Is God Is 2026 ★ 5.9

Runaway Romance 2018 ★ 6.8

My Cousin Rachel 1952 ★ 6.7

My Cousin Rachel 2017 ★ 5.7

UnREAL 2015 ★ 6.6

The Testaments 2026 ★ 8.3

Moebius 2013 ★ 6.6

13 Reasons Why 2017 ★ 7.5