Best Mysterious Stranger Movies & TV Series

The 21 best-rated mysterious stranger movies and TV series on 3eyedraven, ranked by a weighted audience score so the genuinely great rises above one-off perfect ratings. Every title has cast, ratings, trailers and where to watch.

The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power 2022 ★ 7.2
Pale Rider 1985 ★ 7.2
The Lodger: A Story of the London Fog 1927 ★ 7.1
The Dark Valley 2014 ★ 7.0
Storm of the Century 1999 ★ 7.0
In a Day 2006 ★ 7.5
Hearts in Atlantis 2001 ★ 6.8
Tuck Everlasting 2002 ★ 6.7
Meek's Cutoff 2011 ★ 6.5
Edge of the Garden 2011 ★ 6.2
Gutland 2018 ★ 6.0
Don't Hang Up 2016 ★ 6.2
Just My Luck 2006 ★ 6.2
The Prisoner 2009 ★ 5.6
Kill 'em All 2017 ★ 5.7
A House on the Bayou 2021 ★ 5.7
Eleven Days, Eleven Nights 1987 ★ 5.1
The Strangers: Prey at Night 2018 ★ 5.7
The Box 2009 ★ 5.6
The Ninth Passenger 2018 ★ 4.1
Looking Glass 2018 ★ 4.8